What Puppy Lust Has Taught Me About Baby Rabies
I’ve done my fair share of poking fun at people with full-blown Baby Rabies. You know the type – the ones whose biological clocks start BRRRRRRINGING at the very sight of a double-wide Bugaboo stroller. The ones who make new moms a little nervous with such comments to the baby as, “You’re so cute, I could just STEAL YOU!” I’ll admit, I’ve been giving these crazy ladies a hard time. But that’s all going to have to grind to a halt because it’s recently come to my attention that I’ve developed a raging case of PUPPY LUST.
When we’re on The Strand and people are passing by every two seconds with some prancing ball of fur on a leash (or in a stroller – this is Manhattan Beach after all), my IQ dips to that of a three year-old. I point at every single one and say, “Doggie!” or “Look at him go!” or “So tiny!” and other such intelligent observations. If there’s a car driving past with a dog hanging its head out the window, forget it. I’m done. My day is made, but Drew’s is ruined because I won’t stop talking about how there’s truly nothing that expresses sheer joy better than a dog with his tongue in the wind.
I didn’t grow up with dogs (my Mom would dash across the street if she fancied there was a Chihuahua looking at her the wrong way), and I’ve never really considered getting one in my adult life. They always seemed to be about a diaper genie away from having a baby, what with all the waking up at ungodly hours for morning walks and never being able to just set out a bowl of food and water for an overnight trip. But with my puppy obsession reaching new heights, I decided to start volunteering at a local animal shelter to get my fix, hoping this would be enough to cure me.
Drew was a nervous wreck on my first day, convinced I’d be rolling home with a Toyota Highlander stuffed to the brim with Pomeranians. I won’t pretend that wasn’t a real possibility, but to both his and my surprise, I’ve been going the The Lange Foundation* every week for a few months now and have yet to add another four-legged friend to the house. Is it because the dogs aren’t overwhelmingly cute? Oh, I don’t know, why don’t you ask my friend Barney here?
He’s pissed you even asked. Is it because I don’t feel an overwhelming sense of worth in knowing that I’ve made their day a little better? Ricky here does this little lip-smacking thing when he’s satisfied with my petting skills that just about kills me.

Is it because they don’t do the darnest things and make me laugh every time I go in? If you could see Confi’s hilarious gait, with his tiny legs kicking up from side to side when he walks, you wouldn’t be able to keep a straight face either.
But do any of these things make me want to take any of them home on a permanent basis? Well, of course. For about two minutes, until I really think it through. Do I want to surrender the currently un-destroyed state my furniture, take a shower every time I’m covered with slobbery licks, leave work when they get sick, feel terrible about boarding them for a weekend or asking our friends to take them in when we go on vacation? Much as I love them, they just don’t fit with my lifestyle and I don’t feel that I’m missing out on some incredible life experience that would make it all worthwhile to me.
So why can I come to this conclusion with such clarity when it comes to dogs, and remain so confused when it comes to babies? Whom, incidentally, I do NOT excitedly point out on the street. Maybe it’s because the life experience I’m missing out on with a dog is a little more clearly defined to me because of the time I spend walking with them, or because I have cats. But the whole having-a-kid thing remains just a giant fuzzy Unknowable. Perhaps the answer would reveal itself if I experimented with taking in a foreign exchange student or volunteering at a baby-walking facility. Perhaps I should stop making things up like “baby-walking facilities” and just take one of my friends’ babies out for a walk.
Anyone have a baby they want to loan me, in need of some fresh air and exercise?
[insert chirping crickets]
Fine, then does anyone have any words of wisdom about whether spending more time around babies might clarify things for me? Is it only because I’ve never had younger cousins or siblings (Matt, you don’t count since we’re only a year apart) and almost none of my friends out here have babies yet? Am I going to have to go all Elisabeth Shue on everyone, feather my bangs and start having weekly Adventures in Babysitting to get to the bottom of this?
*Boy, I did a terrible job of convincing you all to adopt a dog at Lange! But for those of you who are better people than me, Lange is a wonderful place to find a furry friend (they have cats too!) OR volunteer – we’re always in need of more walkers!










I’ll admit I have a serious case of puppy lust. And a related strain of kitty fanaticism! And nursing a lingering case of baby-obsession. But unlike the pets (we have three) we\’ve decided not to \”bring home\” a baby. A few reasons? Pets don\’t have to 1- audition to get in to the \’best\’ pre-school, 2- be driven to soccer-ballet-swim-dance-classes 5 days a week, and 3- take vacations only in the hot, crowded, expensive summer month.
Phew, that’s a relief our pets won’t have to audition to get into anything – I love mine to death, but they’d never get in. To anything. So ill-behaved!
I do think my friends kids are pretty cute and entertaining so that may sway you IF you had more friends with kids. A coworker of my wife who was on the fence about having kids put it this way: If we were going to make the decision to forgo having a family then we felt like we needed to do something really fabulous with our time like moving to Paris to open a bakery. (Mostly unrealistic.)
They opted to have kids.
In the present I think it is easy to always assume we will be young, hip, energetic, and surrounded by similar friends. (I am 30, by the way.) But it fades. People get older. Some of those friends will decide to start having kids. I am in the middle of Babymania this year as it seems like we know about a dozen friends who are pregnant for the first time. We went to the apple orchard yesterday on a beautiful fall day here in Minnesota and I have admit it did actually seem a little empty just the two of us considering how many families were around.
The thing that terrifies me probably the most is if we decided not to have children and something happened to my wife. Being middle aged and all alone is not a pleasant thought. Here’s a sobering article on the challenges that this poses.
http://newoldage.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/25/aging-without-children/
I know – the thought of losing my husband someday without kids is terrifying, but to be honest, I always picture it happening when I’m well into my seventies or eighties. I hadn’t really thought of what might happen to me if that happened earlier. Yikes! I’m definitely going to check out that article.
Please, PLEASE don\’t consider having kids just \”in case\” you lose your spouse and you don\’t have any. When I was born, my dad had recently been diagnosed with cancer and he passed away when I was 7. My life was forever ruined because of this. When he was sick, my mom had to take care of both of us. When he died, my mom was not a suitable parent due to losing the love of her life. She kicked me out of the house when I was 19 because she said she could not handle me – I was a good kid who made one mistake and I know that if my father was around it would not have happened and I would not be living the terrible life I\’m living now. I was also relentlessly bullied throughout school as I was \”different\” due to not having a father. I have told my mom more than once that she should never have had me. I am choosing not to have children – for many reasons – but the fact that there is always a possibility that the kid could grow up like I had to is a big one.
Don’t worry Sapphire, that would never be the sole (or even main) reason that I would have kids. I’m sorry it sounds like you’ve had such a tough upbringing and can completely understand why you’d be reluctant to chance having your potential kids grow up in the same way. It sounds like you’ve made a well thought-out choice for good reasons.
Those are all reasons to use to give oneself a good push to have kids if it\’s something one thinks one wants, but is also scared, which is totally fine. I personally believe that if I take care of myself and put the time and energy into my social circle, there\’s no reason I won\’t have a solid social support system throughout my life. Social support only fades if you let it by not making it a priority.
And losing a spouse doesn\’t mean you\’ll be alone, if you put the effort into having solid social support. From personal experience, I highly recommend against using your spouse and kid(s) as your only social support. It doesn\’t always work out.
I found that article really interesting and hopeful, not sobering, as a childfree person (minus the weird, sad photo at the top). A quoted study says that elderly people with some mobility issues had the same amount of care regardless if they were parents or not. The study also found that the psychological well-being of non-parents was higher than those of parents.
Still, I do have some fears about being a childfree older adult, too. I think it\’s because my emphasis is on the health and future of myself and my husband rather than the all-consuming focus of a child, which can dampen or hide any future concerns about oneself. Children can take up most of the available energy for worry.
That’s a very interesting point that you sort of lose sight about worrying about yourself when you have someone else to worry about. I wonder if that’s part of the reason non-parents have a higher psychological well-being than parents – they only need to worry about things that are (mostly) in their control – unlike those who have to worry about a children, who you largely can’t control once they’re out of the nest. Though some, of course, will try…
I have a really cute easy kid you can take on walks! We are thinking of renting him out for people to have fun with for a couple hours as a way to offset his expenses.
Oh my, I have to pay for it too?!
I know what you mean about puppy lust. I\’ve got it bad! In fact, when I see people walking their dogs, I talk to the dogs and forget to talk to the humans!
Your volunteer work at the shelter is a great idea. Have you ever considered doing the same thing in the human realm? Children\’s hospitals, church daycares, and schools are always looking for extra help, and there\’s always Big Brothers/Big Sisters and the like. Maybe you could get the same kind of \”fix\” from this volunteer work as you do from your pet volunteerism. Then you\’d have the best of both worlds: lots of love and appreciation from cute little creatures, with the ability to retain your freedom!
I’ve thought about the Big Sister program, and I’m having my husband test it out first by becoming a Big Brother! I might be spreading myself a little too thin with all that, but we’ll see.
Those programs are so awesome. Before I got married and had a kid, I was pretty jazzed about being involved in something like Big Brothers, because it was a way to give something incredibly valuable without having to devote my life to it. When I was a sophomore in college, I actually signed a sort of contract to spend time with a kid who lived in a touch neighborhood in D.C., and it was a really good, though too short experience. If more single or even childless people considered these sorts of programs, there could be some really great outcomes for kids who don’t have a lot of opportunities. A little harder to imagine taking that stuff on when you’ve got kids of your own, but when ours is a little older, I’m thinking about doing it again.
*tough*
True – we’ve also considered adopting teenagers when we’re older for some of the same reasons. It would be nice for our Childfree life to allow us the time later on to help kids who wouldn’t otherwise get it.
I\’m glad I\’m not the only one that, in the middle of traffic, points and squeals: \”Awwwww! Look at the puppy! Isn\’t he cuuuuute?!?!?\” I have a soft spot in my heart for Black Labradors, Dobermanns, and Rotties – I own a black lab mix, and he\’s the best dog I\’ve ever lived with. He knows so many tricks and various words…I think he is smarter than I think he is…which is scary. And his cute little tilted face when you say \”WANNA GO for a WALK?\” haha!
I had many dogs growing up, at one time, we had 4 Dobermann Pinschers and a beautiful breeding pair of cocker spaniels (dumb dogs, but they are incredibly sweet, and have the most soulful eyes). When I was in high school, we had a Rottweiler…and I did everything with that dog. He was MY dog – I walked him, fed him, played with him, trained him – and when I came back after Marine Corps boot camp, I found out that my mom had sold him to a family with kids. She said that he was so sad after I left…he would sit at my bedroom door and whine. I never seen him again…my mom offered to take me to his new home, but I refused…it would have been too painful. But I will never forget how he \”stalked\” the vacuum when I was vacuuming, or his loud, ferocious bark when anyone knocked on the door. Or his content \”smile\” when I was walking him or cuddling with him on my bed.
Oh, see there…I got lost in doggy lust, too. Oops!
My cats loath the vacuum more than anything on earth. I have never heard such hissing. It’s the primary reason I only clean the house once a month. That, and I loath cleaning more than the cats loath the vacuum.
My cat hates the lux (vacuum) too he runs and hides under the bed or heads outside.
Maybe they’re afraid the vacuum views them as just one giant piece of dust they need to suck up?
Hang on, aren\’t you forgetting something? When you have a baby, you aren\’t just getting a baby. You\’re also getting a toddler, a child, a teenager, etc. Judging parenthood by spending time with babies is like deciding to adopt a tiger based on how tiger cubs are. (Granted, tiger babies are awful cute.)
You know they grow up, right? Barney looks to be already fully grown. It ain\’t the same thing.
Oh, I’m aware. I’m famous in my circle of friends for saying that I’m totally fine with the idea of kids until they actually start speaking. I’m fully aware of how I feel about dealing with all the various stages. Babies and teenagers don’t frighten me that much – it’s just everything in between.
I’ve had moments of dog lust, but, like you, it’s pretty clear to me that a dog doesn’t fit into my life. I don’t want to make the sacrifices necessary, namely less time to spend on my already full list of passions and hobbies. I’m sure I’d love the dog if I got one, but why get one knowing I’ll be just as happy (possibly/probably happier) without one? Like you said, I also don’t feel like I’m missing out on anything to make it all worth it.
Even the biggest dog people understand my reasons for not having a dog. But when those same reasons are given to kid people? It’s completely disregarded and I’m told it’s worth it. I think it’s because it’s less socially acceptable for parents to confirm how hard it is and what they’ve given up than it is to say about pets.
The funny thing is that I feel like a “bad” childfree couple because we don’t have a dog. It makes me feel selfish because I don’t want to give up my time, etc. to care for a dog. But when I apply the same reasons to not having a kid, I just feel realistic, not selfish!
Also, I don’t always feel as confident about the kid decision as I do about the dog decision. I think that goes along with social expectations too. Kids are assumed, pets aren’t. You never hear that you’re not a “real woman” or have a meaningless life for not having a pet.
(All that said, should my lifestyle change, I will get a dog. If I lost my husband (God forbid!) or we move to a more pet-friendly area. I say I’m 60% no dog/40% no dog, which is a lot more likely to flip than my 90% no kid/10% kid state.)
The “why mess with a good thing?” mentality you mention above is something I’ve been thinking about a lot lately. I know I’m happy right now – but would I be happy if I added kids into the mix? But I guess it’s not that simple because I might be unhappy in the future if I DON’T have them. Still, it seems strange to act only possible future happiness instead of current happiness.
A couple of years ago I read a post related to regrets, specifically about not having children. (http://apracticalwedding.com/2010/10/reclaiming-wife-the-road-not-taken/) The author, Lauren, write about how it’s okay to mourn paths not taken and that mourning doesn’t mean you chose wrong or regret your choice. The reality is that by taking one path, others are closed. It’s okay to acknowledge what you gave up in order to have your present situation.
There are lots of situations that aren’t always entirely clear cut and the best one can do is choose based on current knowledge of self and situation. Trying to anticipate what your future self might want or feel is an exercise in anxiety (which I do to myself quite often!).
It totally changed my mindset on how I look at life and was the first time I actually felt peaceful with my desire to not parent. (And actually makes me feel much better about other choices, like not experiencing living in Chicago in exchange for a wonderful husband or deciding whether to live in the country or the city.) Thanks for reminding me of this.
I’ve heard of this too – the idea of mourning the path not taken. In some ways it resonates with me, but I think only if it’s given a brief place in your life. I would hate to think I’d be on a continual mourning cycle every time someone has a new baby or gets to visit their kid at college or have a full, happy house at the holidays. I’ll definitely have to write a post on this sometime soon…
I think that a periodic nod and moment of silence for the path not chosen when it arises is perfectly fine. Maybe not every holiday or around every child, but at certain poignant moments. It’s a good self check point too. Am I where I want to be right *now*?
It might sound a bit woo-woo, but when I get really anxious about making the “wrong” choice here, I tell myself that I’ll be a parent in my next life. Then I feel perfectly fine about my decision. If I envision the reverse (kid this life, none next life), it doesn’t feel right.
Very interesting way to think about it!
Mourning and letting go of the path not taken is an important part of life.
People who are unable to do this are the ones who burn themselves out trying to \”have it all.\” No one can actually do everything he or she wants to do in life. That\’s just math and logic and reality, and it\’s immature to think you can be absolutely anything you want to be.
It is totally possible you may be unhappy later without kids even though you\’re happy now. It could happen.
The likelihood of that? Not so sure. I bet it\’s hard to find people who had kids because they just ran out of enjoyable things to do and everything just suddenly felt blah without children. It\’s a common story in pop culture and the media, but how often does that really happen?
And who would actually be honest that it was their reason for having kids? That’s the problem – there’s too much being cloaked in the myths of parenthood for anyone to get a real idea of what’s going on. Luckily, that seems to be changing, if slowly.
You’re right. We don’t live in a society where reproductive choices are debated objectively, openly, and honestly. There are still huge taboos driven by pressure to say what you’re supposed to say whether it’s true or not.
OOOH Oooh! I know someone who did exactly that! I was holding her new (second) baby a few years ago and asked her… “How DID you decide WHEN to have a baby? Like what made it tick over into a real decision?”
Her answer, no word of a lie : “Ah. I was bored with going to the pub.”
And I know her well enough to know this was her serious answer.
*footnote – she now constantly complains strenuously about the dismal state of parenthood and how miserable she is…and she totally misses going to the pub. Probably because that is where her husband is all of the time now.
I always have puppy lust even though I already have two
For me, they are a huge step towards the responsibility of taking care of child, especially since my younger dog has epilepsy.
Your line of thinking is exactly what brought me to offer to babysit for my friends\’ kids. It\’ll either ease the baby-wanting thoughts, or completely backfire and make it worse.
You’ll have to let us know whether it works! You really ARE getting a taste of parenthood in trying to manage a dog with epilepsy! Poor thing, I hope he/she’s doing well.
I don’t know why it didn’t occur to me to comment on this specifically, but I have a rescue dog (much baggage, special needs in a different sort of way) and also have young kids (dog came first). The dog was perhaps good prep for the kids, but a few years in and I find myself resenting the dog, because it’s the dog that is making me feel trapped when I expected it would be the kids. I think the “problem” is that the kids move along in life – they crawl, then they walk, then they talk. You work hard as a parent and your efforts are reflected in their growing abilities and achievements. My daughter held the door for someone at the store and I just about died because something I said to her sunk in. Kids are challenging but as they grow, it’s really fun to get out and do cool things. We want to go apple picking this weekend and soon we will be back to a semi-normal life of restaurants and vacations and we can hire a babysitter when we want to do those things without the kids. My older kid is fully talking now and it’s a hoot to hear what she has to say. But the dog. I love him to pieces but for the rest of his life he will be pretty much the same no matter what I do. It’s like permanent Groundhog Day.
So I guess my point is that the responsibility of a dog is probably good prep for kids in that you have to account for their needs (and you get used to dealing with poop), but it doesn’t really prepare you for sharing your life with a kid who grows and changes over time and the accompanying ups and downs.
That’s a really interesting perspective – I’d never quite thought of pets that way, but of course, you’re right. There’s probably a brief period of change if you get them very, very young as they learn to sit, heel, use a litterbox, whatever, but after that, it’s pretty much the same. In a way though, I kind of like that. Maybe I value stability more than I thought.
My personal opinion, first dog was a rescue dog, if I’d known what I was letting myself in for (six month’s special needs because he had been neglected, then 3 months palliative care for terminal bone cancer) I would NEVER have done it, BUT I did, and am glad I did, and I am NOBODY’S idea of a masochist or doormat but loving him and having to put him first made me a bigger, better, less neurotic and more loving person.
I discovered strengths and compassion I didn’t know I had, and aside from the softer stuff I grew far more self-respect in those 9 months than I could ever have had sneering at people with their poop-scoops and their morning walks in the rain, which I used to do all the time as a teenager. I also grew a heightened sense of perspective and an ability to worry less about the small stuff in life, and that stayed with me permanently afterwards.
Like I posted earlier I went from thinking dog poop was the grossest thing on earth to being glad when he did a nice solid poop because it meant his stomach wasn’t upset that day, things I would never have credited before.
Dunno if kids are the same but I do know that the idea of “try before you buy” gives a vry distorted picture, because you get the hassles and poop under your nails, without the love and the bond and the long-term benefits and intangibles which are the whole point of the thing.
Having to spend so much energy on someone else really does have a way of making the small stuff totally unimportant – which is definitely a perk!
That’s what I love about my dog…he is the same as he was ten years ago…(Ok, a little greyer and grumpier) but he is far more constant than any person I know.
There was no period of Beiber infatuation, no teen pregnancy, no hormonal screaming about wanting a thong when he turned eight. He has never flushed my keys down the loo, mooned a nun… the police have never had to bring him to the door shamefaced for smoking out behind the Circle K. He likes ball, walkies and other dogs butts, in that order. That I can handle.
I like knowing what I am coming home to.
There IS something fabulously comforting about the simplicity of their wants and needs, isn’t there?